Major landowner federations to support AMR against Nordic Mining ASA (NOM) in the Norwegian Supreme Court
Arnold Rørholt, lawyer and AMR’s Chairman, welcomes the 3rd party intervention in favour of AMR:
“The intervention will ensure that the Supreme Court, as opposed to the courts of lower instance, appreciates the principal nature of the case and the Constitutional issues underpinning it, and interprets the Mineral Act in light of these – to the favour of AMR.”
“The Western part of the Engebø garnet and rutile province contains around half of the proven reserves in the Engebø deposit, as well as a majority of inferred resources and will support a highly profitable 50 years plus fully underground mining project without a need for deposits on land or in the sea” continues Rørholt.
Arctic Mineral Resources (AMR) and the federations argue that the two mineral categories – owned by the landowners and the state, respectively – have equal rights. Neither obliterate nor take preference over the other. NOM/NRU argues that extraction rights to state-owned minerals eliminate the need to obtain rights to landowner-owned minerals in a given deposit. AMR and the federations argue that AMR’s mineral rights to garnet prohibit NRU from mining the Western half of the Engebø garnet and rutile deposit. The Ministry of Industry, Trade and Fisheries is currently processing AMR’s application for an operating licence in AMR’s part of the deposit.
The judgement in the case from the Courts of lower instance gave AMR a partial win; garnet in the Engebø mineral province is owned by the landowners. The verdict opened for NRU to extract ore on AMR’s mineral lease area; however, if AMR could prove to the authorities the commercial viability of mining garnet on a stand-alone basis, NRU would be obliged to compensate AMR for the value of garnet less a share of its operating costs.
AMR has appealed the judgement to the Supreme Court. Two of the key landowner federations in Norway, NORSKOG and the Norwegian Forest Owners’ Federation (‘Norges Skogeierforbund’), have now declared 3rd party intervention to AMR’s benefit in the appeal before the Supreme Court, as the outcome of the appeal is important to their 35 000 members. This means that they will appear before the Supreme Court with their own lawyers to argue against upholding the judgement from the Courts of lower instance. Upholding the verdict would represent a confiscation or a limitation of private property interest in violation of the Constitution of Norway, with a profound negative impact on numerous Norwegian landowners.
Arnold RørholtStyrelederTel:+47 465 44 email@example.com
About Arctic Mineral Resources
About Arctic Mineral Resources AS
AMR develops and operates innovative and resource efficient mineral industry assets in close cooperation with partners.
AMR demands operations to deliver across three key pillars:
Profit – Planet – People
For additional informasjon regarding the company, please see www.arcminres.com
Subscribe to releases from Arctic Mineral Resources
Subscribe to all the latest releases from Arctic Mineral Resources by registering your e-mail address below. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Latest releases from Arctic Mineral Resources
Skogeierorganisasjonene erklærer partshjelp for Høyesterett til fordel for Arctic Mineral Resources AS26.1.2023 11:07:03 CET | Pressemelding
Oslo, 25. januar 2023: To av de største grunneierorganisasjonene i Norge, NORSKOG og Norges Skogeierforbund erklærer partshjelp til støtte for Arctic Mineral Resources AS sin anke til Høyesterett av lagmannsrettdommen i søksmål mot Nordic Rutile AS, et heleid datterselskap av Nordic Mining ASA.
AMR appeals case against Nordic Mining to the Supreme Court30.11.2022 11:24:12 CET | Press release
Oslo, Norway, 28 November 2022: Arctic Mineral Resources AS (“AMR”) has appealed the judgement from Borgarting court of appeals in the lawsuit against Nordic Rutile AS (“NRU”), a subsidiary of Nordic Mining ASA (“NOM”). Should AMR succeed in the appeal, NOM will lose about half of the proven reserves of its Engebo project due to insufficient mineral rights.
ARCTIC MINERAL RESOURCES anker til Høyesterett29.11.2022 12:24:00 CET | Pressemelding
Oslo, 28. november 2022: Arctic Mineral Resources AS (AMR) har anket dommen fra Borgarting lagmannsrett i søksmål mot Nordic Rutile AS (NRU), et heleid datterselskap av Nordic Mining ASA. «Dommen bygger på feil forståelse av rettshistorien som fører til feil rettsanvendelse. Dommen skaper en betydelig risiko for alle aktørene i bransjen som i dag driver etablerte uttak og fratar grunneierne i Norge milliardverdier. Dommen baner vei for ikke bærekraftige løsninger med både grunneiere, mineralnæring, samfunn og stat som store tapere», sier advokat og styreleder i AMR, Arnold Rørholt. «Anken bygger på den fremstillingen av faktum og juss som mindretallet i lagmannsretten, som ga AMR fullt medhold samt full dekning av sakskostnader, bygde på. Vi har stor tro på at Høyesterett vil dømme i samsvar med mindretallet», fortsetter Rørholt.
ARCTIC MINERAL RESOURCES with a partial victory in a lawsuit against Nordic Rutile AS, a fully owned subsidiary of Nordic Mining ASA26.10.2022 11:54:00 CEST | Press release
Oslo 25 October 2022; A partial victory in the court of appeal with Arctic Mineral Resources AS ("AMR") securing a unanimous judgement to the effect that garnet continues to be a landowner-owned mineral in poly-mineral deposits, with a potentially commercial deposit of state-owned minerals, and a dissenting ruling (1-2) with the minority in favour of AMR's claim that Nordic Rutile AS ("NRU") cannot extract or utilise garnet on properties where AMR has mineral lease agreements with landowners.
ARCTIC MINERAL RESOURCES VANT DELVIS FRAM I SØKSMÅLET MOT NORDIC RUTILE25.10.2022 15:55:52 CEST | Pressemelding
Oslo, 25. oktober 2022: Delvis seier, og dissens (1 av 3) hvor Arctic Mineral Resources AS vinner frem med at granat tilhører grunneier i gårsdagens dom fra Borgarting lagmannsrett.