Business Wire

Hogan Lovells White Paper Calls for Flexibility as the EU Establishes Its First-ever Regulatory Framework Enabling the Launch of Autonomous Vehicles


Global law firm Hogan Lovells has today shared its recommendations on the future of Europe’s regulatory framework for autonomous vehicles (AVs), as the European Commission takes an important first step in submitting a Draft EU ADS Regulation to all 27 Member States ahead of a Public Consultation in November.

The regulatory framework published in late September 2021 will be used to help shape the future of AVs across the EU and will have far reaching implications on the AV industry in Europe for years to come.

The Draft EU ADS Regulation sets out the type-approval rules for AVs with regard to their automated driving system (ADS) to create a harmonised pathway for (SAE/ISO) “Level 4” or “fully automated” vehicles to be deployed on public roads across Member States – with no human driver. It also establishes aggregate safety metrics that will be used to benchmark performance, and ultimately will be used as a measurement for allowing AV testing and deployment.

The Hogan Lovells White Paper “The Road to Autonomous Vehicles” issued today identifies three key recommendations for a legal framework for AVs, which will guide regulatory developments at an EU and national level. They include:

  1. A broad, holistic and forward-looking approach to type-approval across Europe is important. The regulatory framework needs to be as flexible as possible. At a minimum, the existing system for type-approval should be used as a foundation and should not be undone for AVs/ADSs only.

  2. The assumption of regulatory responsibility and proof of safety concept should be considered as the decisive factor for regulations. Expertise is key when it comes to putting AVs onto public roads in the market and needs to be considered when allocating roles and responsibilities for different economic operators.

  3. Avoiding ambiguities (in particular to the existing regulatory framework), inconsistencies and the use of unclear terms and definitions that may lead to interpretation issues and delay the development and commercialisation of AVs.

The Draft EU ADS Regulation is part of a broader maturation in Europe’s AV regulatory environment. Other promising efforts are currently being made by France, Germany and the Netherlands, although Germany appears to be deviating from current existing broad definitions and a flexible approach applied at the EU level. The White Paper highlights that a harmonised approach across Europe providing adequate flexibility will be key for the long-term success of AVs.

Patrick Ayad, Global Leader of Mobility and Transportation at Hogan Lovells, said:

“This is a key piece of research on the future of Europe’s regulatory framework for autonomous vehicles.”

“We have an exciting opportunity to introduce autonomous vehicles in Europe. Current efforts made within Europe are encouraging and align well with the recommendations that we have made in our White Paper today. We need to take a broader and holistic approach to type approval as this will be even more valuable and beneficial for this purpose. Technological innovations, emerging new mobility solutions, as well as commercial and corporate partnerships changing the industry landscape call for a flexible framework – this needs to apply across Europe and individual Member States to work.”

Key highlights from the White Paper include:

- AV technology and the industry landscape are evolving rapidly. Developing an automated driving system (ADS) remains a highly-resource intensive endeavour, requiring extensive technical and specialised expertise.

- The challenge facing regulators is to provide a legal framework to allow for commercial deployment across Europe. This means setting appropriate “type-approval” requirements that meet the dual purposes of ensuring the technology is safe as well as facilitating commercial deployment in a way that will deliver the value the EU Commission has envisaged.

- Steps taken by the French, German and Dutch Governments are encouraging in that they seek to set out the legal basis for the approval of ISO/SAE Level 4 driving automation directly, and not lower-level human driver-assistance systems.

- The shift from conventional vehicles to AVs is a unique and disruptive scenario: it is the first time that not only the vehicle but also the driver (the ADS) are being regulated and type-approved.

- Innovation calls for flexibility. Regulating innovation calls for the same. An open and flexible approach has proven successful for AV testing over many years, building on - rather than replacing - existing regulatory concepts. This same lesson should be applied when it comes to the key question of defining which entity (or group of entities) should be responsible for presenting the AV - that is, the base vehicle and the ADS - to a regulator for type-approval.

- While the European Commission appears to be effectively addressing this issue under its forthcoming ADS Type Approval Implementing Act (which is expected to be in place by July 2022), it seems that the German Government takes a different approach under its current draft for an ordinance implementing the newly adopted changes to road traffic laws enabling regular operation of SAE/ISO Level 4 AVs, which, contrary to existing laws, introduces a new definition for “manufacturer” that refers to the “vehicle manufacturer”.

Hogan Lovells is one of the world's leading law firms in its dedication to an industry sector focused-approach, enabling us to advise our clients in a sector-focused manner, across practice groups, borders and industries.

In 2020, we created a new global Mobility and Transportation sector group, bringing together our already established industry sectors Automotive (and Mobility) and Aerospace and Defence as well as our new industry sector Transport and Logistics, to better represent the rapid changes facing the Mobility and Transportation world.

The full White Paper can be accessed here.


To view this piece of content from, please give your consent at the top of this page.

Contact information

Sarah Downey
Senior Public Relations Adviser
+44 20 7296 2863

Mireya Berteau
Senior Business Development Manager
+33 1 53 67 46 95

Demet Fidanci
Corporate Communications Advisor
+49 211 13 68 373

About Business Wire

Business Wire
Business Wire
24 Martin Lane
EC4R 0DR London

+44 20 7626 1982

(c) 2018 Business Wire, Inc., All rights reserved.

Business Wire, a Berkshire Hathaway company, is the global leader in multiplatform press release distribution.

Subscribe to releases from Business Wire

Subscribe to all the latest releases from Business Wire by registering your e-mail address below. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Latest releases from Business Wire

KPMG Reports Global Revenues of $32.13 Billion for Fy21, Focus on Strategy Enables 10% Growth9.12.2021 01:01:00 CET | Press release

KPMG International announced today annual aggregated revenues for KPMG firms globally of $32.13 billion for the fiscal year ending 30 September 2021 (FY21). Reporting a 10% increase in US dollar revenues from FY20, this follows an extensive period of investment and focus on priority services and solutions addressing the challenges faced by businesses across the globe. Strong growth across functions: Advisory growing at 17%, Audit at 4% and Tax & Legal Services at 8%. During FY21, the global organization committed to a more than $1.5 billion investment to focus on a multi-year program to accelerate the delivery of its global environmental, societal and governance (ESG) plan and solutions. KPMG firms are focused on building an inclusive and diverse culture and have increased female diversity among leadership ranks to 27% of partners and directors. “2021 was a strong year for KPMG. We achieved outstanding growth in a challenging business climate, unveiled KPMG: Our Impact Plan to help dri

New Global Survey Finds Consumers Are Becoming More Selective About Where, When and How They Share Information with Brands9.12.2021 01:01:00 CET | Press release

The mobile app experience company Airship has today published a new report which highlights new consumer behaviour on mobile and their expectations from brands. Based on a survey of more than 9,000 consumers across seven countries, including the U.K, France, Germany, U.S, Australia, Singapore and India, the report found that 40% of global respondents are more likely to continue receiving brand communications if they are given controls over purpose, frequency and channel. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: Information consumers are willing to share with brands for personalised interactions and special incentives (Graphic: Business Wire) The survey results show a strong and growing consumer preference for mobile apps, with 70% of UK respondents on average using apps across all industries more or about the same since the pandemic began — highlighting the opportunity to establish positive feedback lo

Seagen Announces Updated Results from Pivotal HER2CLIMB Trial Evaluating TUKYSA ® (tucatinib) in Patients with HER2-Positive Breast Cancer with Brain Metastases9.12.2021 00:00:00 CET | Press release

Seagen Inc. (Nasdaq:SGEN) today announced the presentation of new data from exploratory analyses from the pivotal HER2CLIMB trial showing that improvement in overall survival (OS) was maintained after an additional 15.6 months of follow-up when TUKYSA® (tucatinib) was combined with trastuzumab and capecitabine in patients with HER2-positive metastatic breast cancer (MBC) who had stable or active brain metastases. The data were featured today in a spotlight poster (Abstract #PD4-04) at the 2021 San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium (SABCS). “The risk of breast cancer spreading to the brain is more pronounced for patients with aggressive subtypes of breast cancer, including HER2-positive breast cancer,” said Nancy U. Lin, M.D., Director of the Metastatic Breast Cancer Program in the Susan F. Smith Center for Women’s Cancers at Dana-Farber in Boston, MA. “These analyses provide a hopeful outcome for patients with HER2-positive metastatic breast cancer when cancer has spread to the brain as

IFF Declares Dividend for Fourth Quarter 20218.12.2021 22:15:00 CET | Press release

IFF (NYSE: IFF) announced that its Board of Directors has declared a regular quarterly cash dividend of $0.79 per share of its common stock, payable on January 7, 2022 to shareholders of record as of December 28, 2021. Welcome to IFF At IFF (NYSE: IFF), an industry leader in food, beverage, scent, health and biosciences, science and creativity meet to create essential solutions for a better world – from global icons to unexpected innovations and experiences. With the beauty of art and the precision of science, we are an international collective of thinkers who partners with customers to bring scents, tastes, experiences, ingredients and solutions for products the world craves. Together, we will do more good for people and planet. Learn more at, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn. View source version on information Michael DeVeau Chief Investor Relations & Communications Officer 212.708.71

Walton Global Announces a $63.7 Million Distribution to Investors8.12.2021 21:00:00 CET | Press release

Walton Global, a real estate investment and land asset management company with US$3.4 billion under management is pleased to announce a total of CAD $63.7 million in distributions that will be made to investors within various corporations: WIGI Restructured Bond Corporation (WIGI RBC), McConachie Management Corporation and Roll-up Corporation (RUC). The distributions are scheduled throughout the month of December 2021. Roll-Up Corporation (RUC) A distribution of approximately CAD $55 million was approved on November 15, 2021, by the Walton-managed Roll-Up Corporation (RUC). The distribution was paid to shareholders of RUC on December 1, 2021. This is the third distribution made to investors in RUC, with this distribution representing $0.082 per share. RUC investors have received a total of CAD $104 million in distributions since the formation of the entity in 2018. RUC was formed through the amalgamation of 134 Canadian pre-development land entities and has more than 28,141 shareholder

KartRider: Drift Closed Beta Starts Today8.12.2021 20:58:00 CET | Press release

The next entry in Nexon’s phenomenally successful KartRider racing franchise is here! Cross-platform sensation, the free-to-play KartRider: Drift, will launch its Closed Beta at 4pm Pacific today, ending on December 15th at 5am Pacific. Access to the KartRider: Drift Closed Beta is available for PC on Nexon’s launcher and Steam, in addition to being available to console players on PlayStation®4 and Xbox One. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: KARTRIDER: DRIFT CLOSED BETA STARTS TODAY - Closed Beta for Online Cross-Platform, Free-to-Play Party Racing Game Kicks Off (Graphic: Business Wire) Gearing up to deliver new thrills in the beloved Nexon racing franchise, KartRider: Drift offers unparalleled character and kart customization. Karts can be tailored as never before, allowing players to transform their rides to reflect their inner racing persona. To help make sure your ride represents who you ar

Rimini Street Wins Frost & Sullivan Best Practices Award for Third-Party Enterprise Software Support Services Company of the Year8.12.2021 19:00:00 CET | Press release

Rimini Street, Inc. (Nasdaq: RMNI), a global provider of enterprise software products and services, the leading third-party support provider for Oracle and SAP software products and a Salesforce partner, today announced it has been awarded the 2021 Asia Pacific Best Practices Award for Third-Party Enterprise Software Support Services Company of the Year by leading research and consulting firm Frost & Sullivan. The recognition recognizes Rimini Street's commitment to help clients maximize returns on their enterprise software and technology investments to better enable innovation to drive competitive advantage and growth. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: Rimini Street Wins Frost & Sullivan Best Practices Award for Third-Party Enterprise Software Support Services Company of the Year (Graphic: Business Wire) Award Honors Innovation in Client Service Excellence The Frost & Sullivan Best Practices Aw