Effissimo Releases Presentation Explaining Proposal to Appoint Independent Investigators at Toshiba
Effissimo Capital Management (“Effissimo”), the largest shareholder of Toshiba Corporation (“Toshiba”) (TYO:6502) through the funds it manages, today released a presentation explaining the reasons behind its proposal for an independent investigation into reported irregularities surrounding Toshiba’s July 2020 Annual General Meeting of Shareholders (“AGM”). Effissimo’s proposal will be voted on by Toshiba’s shareholders at an extraordinary shareholders meeting scheduled for March 18, 2021.
The full proposal in English can be found here.
Supplementing its letter to shareholders dated February 24, 2021, Effissimo’s presentation explains its proposal for an independent investigation into the irregular handling of shareholder voting and shareholder pressure at the closely contested AGM, which Toshiba’s conflicted Audit Committee’s self-audit fails to address.
The presentation provides data showing discrepancies in the claimed delivery times of mailed ballots said by Toshiba’s vote tabulator to have been delivered past the AGM deadline and not counted. It also examines the artificially limited scope and conclusions of Toshiba’s Audit Committee’s investigations into shareholder pressure and vote tampering allegations.
Finally, the presentation provides a detailed historical context of chronic governance and oversight dysfunction at Toshiba that has persisted despite the installation of new management in 2017.
Vote Delivery & Tabulation
- Inexplicable Delay in Ballot Delivery: Effissimo’s own field tests and review of other Japanese companies’ AGMs confirm Japan Post, in accordance with its own service guidelines, normally takes at most three days to deliver domestic mail. But Toshiba’s vote tabulator insists that it took four days, in breach of Postal Law, for ballots to be delivered.
- Uncounted Ballots: There are still nearly 1,000—but possibly more than 1,600—additionally reported ballots that have yet to be audited by the Audit Committee due to claims they were delivered too late to be counted. These ballots should have ordinarily arrived prior to the vote deadline, absent the inexplicable delay in ballot delivery.
- Treatment of Blank Ballots: Mailed ballots made up more than one-third of Toshiba’s quorum at the AGM – a substantial portion of shareholder participation. Roughly 17% of ballots were blank, which Toshiba treated as favorable to management. While lawful, this is clearly an anti-dissident practice that Toshiba could have abandoned after a shareholder proposal in this regard back in 2015.
- Decline in Shareholder Participation: In a closely contested vote that attracted intense interest and attention, participation at the AGM declined by three percentage points year-over-year, providing grounds for suspicion that voter suppression in fact occurred.
- Multiple Institutional Investors Absent from AGM: Credible media outlets have reported that shareholders were “pressured” and/or “threatened” with a probe if they voted against Toshiba management. Toshiba’s voting records indicate that some institutional shareholders that normally vote as a matter of course did not vote at the AGM. Effissimo’s confidential survey confirmed that multiple shareholders were pressured.
Although it may appear complex, the heart of issue is simple. Effissimo believes there should be an independent investigation as opposed to a self-audit by a conflicted Audit Committee.
The Audit Committee, chaired by a director whose reappointment was opposed by more than 40 percent of shareholders at the AGM, is conflicted and is naturally reticent to conduct an uninhibited investigation of possible wrongdoing at the AGM. This conflict manifests itself in the Audit Committee’s reviews and investigations, which we suspect are deliberately limited in scope at the outset to produce a pre-determined result.
The right to vote is what is at stake. Shareholders must not passively accept the Board’s explanations at face value and allow the status quo of weak governance to persist. Failure to perform a thorough and independent investigation will set a harmful precedent not only for Toshiba but also for corporate Japan as a whole.
Contact information for the press regarding this matter
VOX Global Japan K.K.
Minoru Koshida / Rie Sugiyama / Ayako Hitomi
TEL: +81-80-2208-9698 / +81-80-2042-2852 / +81-70-3624-3081
About Business Wire
(c) 2018 Business Wire, Inc., All rights reserved.
Business Wire, a Berkshire Hathaway company, is the global leader in multiplatform press release distribution.
Subscribe to releases from Business Wire
Subscribe to all the latest releases from Business Wire by registering your e-mail address below. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Latest releases from Business Wire
CGTN: A City on the Rebound: How Hong Kong Can Move Forward13.4.2021 19:57:00 CEST | Press release
The past two years have been tough on the world, not just due to the pandemic but also the geopolitical volatility that has roiled many countries and regions. In East Asia, the financial hub of Hong Kong has experienced its fair share of difficulties, but as life slowly returns to normal, problems that have plagued the city for decades remain. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210413006039/en/ (Photo: Business Wire) The city's brief history is well-documented – its humble industrialization in the 1970s coupled with the entrepreneurial spirit of its residents saw it become a bastion of wealth at a time when that part of the world was still economically stagnant. Coupled with a liberalized financial system and generous policies, the city catapulted itself toward the top, competing with mega-cities such as London and New York City. For all its glitz and glamour, Hong Kong contained contradictions that boiled over i
Tigo Intellectual Property Infringement Lawsuit against APS Continues to Grow13.4.2021 19:53:00 CEST | Press release
Tigo Energy, Inc., the solar industry worldwide leader in Flex-MLPE (Module Level Power Electronics), has filed a new lawsuit against Altenergy Power Systems (“APsystems”), in addition to its current ongoing case. The complaint includes four new patent infringement claims, as well as an additional claim from a patent asserted in the previously-filed lawsuit. The complaint was filed in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California. The total number of Patents-in-Suit in both cases now stands at six. The complaint includes all APsystems legal entities in the US as well as in China. The new complaint alleges that APsystems’ Sunspec-compliant products infringe the following U.S. patents: 8,653,689, 9,584,021, 9,966,848, 10,333,405, and 8,933,321. The complaint centers around various systems and methods used in the PV module rapid shutdown unit. Tigo’s industry leading solar equipment provides optimized, monitored and safe solar to protect this critical infrastruc
Maxon Announces Cinema 4D S2413.4.2021 18:05:00 CEST | Press release
Maxon, the developers of professional software solutions for motion designers and visual effects artists, today announced Cinema 4D Subscription Release 24 (S24). The latest subscription-only release of Maxon’s 3D application allows users to easily browse and obtain models, materials and other assets, and to intuitively place them within the scene. The release also includes key workflow enhancements and a sneak peek at continued progress on the Scene Nodes and Scene Manager interfaces to the new core. Cinema 4D S24 is immediately available for subscription customers. For perpetual license holders of Cinema 4D a release is scheduled later this year that will incorporate the features of S24, as well as future enhancements. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210413005918/en/ Maxon Cinema 4D S24 features placement tools, a new asset browser, animation workflow enhancements, and continued development on powerful nodes
Maxon Announces Redshift for macOS Including Native Support for M1-Powered Macs13.4.2021 18:05:00 CEST | Press release
Today, Maxon announced the immediate availability of Redshift for macOS including support for M1-powered Macs as well as Apple’s Metal Graphics API. Redshift, the award-winning, production-ready renderer, offers a rich feature set including ray switches, flexible shading networks, motion blur, AOVs, deep output, layered EXR and much more. Unlike other GPU renderers, Redshift is a biased renderer that enables artists to adjust the quality of individual techniques in order to get the best performance/quality balance for production. As a Universal solution, Redshift is optimized for high-end performance across both M1- and Intel-powered Macs. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210413005903/en/ Redshift for macOS signifies a milestone, bringing cutting-edge cinematic rendering to Mac artists. (Graphic: Business Wire) Redshift for macOS signifies a milestone, bringing cutting-edge cinematic rendering to Mac artists. A
Golden Euro-spiller tok rekordgevinst på € 3 millioner13.4.2021 17:29:00 CEST | Pressemelding
Champagnen flyter og feiringen er godt i gang hos Golden Euro Casino, etter at en heldig spiller tok jackpoten og vant en monstergevinst på € 3 746 291. Spillerens gevinst kom på Realtime Gamings enormt populære automat Aztec Millions. Det er den største gevinsten gjennom tidene på det progressive jackpotspillet, og hos Golden Euro. For å starte økten gjorde den 49 år gamle spilleren et kredittkortinnskudd på € 27, og hentet Golden Euros ettertraktede innskuddsbonus på 50 %. Dermed hadde hun € 54 til å spille med. Gevinsten kom fra en liten enkeltinnsats på € 5 plassert fra smarttelefonen hennes. Da hjulene stoppet opp og jackpoten ble utløst, ble spilleren umiddelbart mangemillionær. Adrian Berger hos Golden Euro Casino uttaler: “Vi er så glade for at en av spillerne våre har landet den største jackpotgevinsten noensinne på Realtime Gamings Aztec Millions. “Jeg snakket med spilleren kort tid etter at hun bekreftet gevinsten sin og hun var utrolig opprømt, selv om det at hun nå er en m
Agthia Embarks on Transformational Journey with its Strategy to Become an F&B Leader by 202513.4.2021 17:06:00 CEST | Press release
Agthia Group PJSC revealed its long-term strategy to become an F&B leader in the Middle East, North Africa and Pakistan (MENAP) region and beyond by 2025. The strategy is built on three strategic pillars (growth, efficiency and capability) and is designed to extend the Group’s market leadership, provide significant value for all stakeholders and continue to drive profitability growth with a consumer-centric approach. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210413005841/en/ Khalifa Sultan Al Suwaidi - Chairman - Agthia Group (Photo: AETOSWire) The Abu Dhabi-based organisation is engaged in manufacturing, distribution and marketing of a wide range of F&B products, including popular regional brands such as Al Ain (water), Al Foah (dates), Al Faysal Bakery & Sweets (bakery) and Grand Mills (flour and bakery) among others. Khalifa Sultan Al Suwaidi, Chairman, Agthia Group, said: “The strategy will unleash the full potentia
FRISS Acquires Terrene Labs to Expand Underwriting Efficiency13.4.2021 17:03:00 CEST | Press release
FRISS, the market leader in AI-powered fraud, risk and compliance solutions for P&C insurance carriers, today announced the acquisition of Terrene Labs. Industry leaders in providing Commercial Insurance providers with comprehensive Risk Insights, Terrene will be a fundamental addition to the FRISS product family. Commercial lines underwriters now have access to thousands of actionable insights within just 5 seconds, replacing a disjointed manual and limited enrichment process that previously took up to a week and delayed policies for quality customers. This press release features multimedia. View the full release here: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210413005837/en/ FRISS acquires Terrene Labs and welcomes them to their family. (Graphic: Business Wire) “We’re bringing commercial lines to the digital age together,” remarked FRISS CEO and Co-founder Jeroen Morrenhof. “True risk insights were always hard to access and we’re changing that. Combined with the analytics capabilitie