
Scientific Beta welcomes updated TCFD guidance and renews criticism of EU Climate Transition and Paris-Aligned Benchmark Regulation
Press Release - Boston, London, Nice, Paris, Singapore, Tokyo, October 21, 2021
Scientific Beta welcomes updated TCFD guidance and renews criticism of EU Climate Transition and Paris-Aligned Benchmark Regulation
Index provider reiterates warnings against use of enterprise-value based carbon intensity and regards integration of implied temperature rise metrics into portfolio construction as premature
On 15 October 2021, the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) updated its 2017 guidelines on implementing its recommendations that aim to promote more informed financial decisions in relation to the risks of climate change.1
The updated guidance:
- Promotes more granular or explicit disclosure of risks and opportunities identified by reporting organisations and how these impact their strategies
- Introduces significant revisions to the disclosures of metrics and targets to:
- Encourage the uptake of indicators that are relevant across industries and of related targets
- Require disclosure of Scope 1, Scope 2 and material Scope 3 emissions
- Require the financial sector to disclose its financed emissions and the extent to which its activities align with the goals of the Paris Agreement
With respect to the supplemental guidance for the financial sector pertaining to the Metrics and Targets pillar of the recommendations, Scientific Beta welcomes two major changes relative to the draft proposals on which the TCFD sought feedback. First, the TCFD reaffirms Weighted Average Carbon Intensity as recommended disclosure2 for funds, products and strategies (while also requiring the disclosure of financed emissions, where possible). Second, it adopts a more cautious approach in respect of disclosure of alignment with Paris-Agreement-consistent temperature scenarios.
“The TCFD is to be commended for taking an evidence-based stance on the evolution of metrics and targets and reversing proposals that would have provided further incentives to counterproductive action by investors,” comments ESG Director Frédéric Ducoulombier who penned Scientific Beta’s contribution to the TCFD consultation.
“The prudent approach of the TCFD in respect of portfolio alignment is befitting the lack of maturity and convergence of methodologies in that area and we salute the work commissioned by the organisation to try and establish bases for the development of robust and convergent portfolio alignment tools,” says Ducoulombier.
“While there is understandable interest in financed emissions as a potential carbon footprinting approach for varied financial activities and investments, it should not be allowed to guide security selection and issuer engagement, notably because its reliance on enterprise value introduces capital market volatility into carbon intensity measurement and obscures the relationship to real-world emissions as we have documented in published research3. While not perfect, revenues-based carbon intensity, as endorsed by the TCFD since 2017, is a superior metric for these applications.”, he adds.
“The integration of climate considerations into investment management must be based on robust data and fit-for-purpose metrics and methodologies whether its primary focus is on managing climate-related risks and opportunities or on promoting real-world climate change mitigation. The European regulator has erred in the matter and bears responsibility for the proliferation of greenwashing strategies claiming EU labels,” says Scientific Beta CEO Noël Amenc, who co-authored a February 2020 report with Ducoulombier that warned of the unintended consequences of the EU regulation then in the making.4
“It is thus a source of comfort and hope that the TCFD, despite a difficult political context, chose to revise its guidance in a manner that preserves established and relevant metrics for climate-related investments, strengthens the issuer-level disclosures on which they are based, and takes a careful, multi-pronged, approach to strengthening the bases for the integration of forward-looking climate-related data in investment management”, he adds.
1 The TCFD was established by the Financial Stability Board, an international body that monitors and makes recommendations about the global financial system. Financial regulators worldwide have endorsed TCFD recommendations with the European Union, Japan, the United Kingdom, Brazil, Switzerland, Singapore and Hong Kong having set, or announced they would set, reporting requirements aligning with the work of the TCFD. The TCFD recommendations are organized around four pillars: Governance, Strategy, Risk Management and Metrics and Targets.
2 The TCFD distinguishes between recommended indicators that financial institutions “should disclose” and additional carbon exposure and footprinting metrics that they “should consider” for reporting. Weighted Average Carbon Intensity (WACI) defined as the average, based on portfolio weights, of the issuer-level ratios of Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions to revenues was the sole recommended indicator until the October 2021 update (which added financed emissions to be calculated according to the standards being developed by the Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials (PCAF)). The draft guidelines had proposed requiring the disclosure of “financed emissions in line with PCAF’s methodology and WACI, if relevant (…) with WACI and other carbon footprint metrics (…) remaining as ‘should consider’ metrics.”
3Carbon intensity bumps on the way to net zero, Frédéric Ducoulombier and Victor Liu, The Journal of Impact & ESG Investing, Spring 2021, Volume 1, Issue 3, pp. 59–73.
4Unsustainable Proposals: A critical appraisal of the TEG Final Report on climate benchmarks and benchmarks' ESG disclosures and remedial proposals, Noël Amenc and Frédéric Ducoulombier, Scientific Beta, February 2020.
About Scientific Beta:
Scientific Beta aims to be the first provider of a smart factor and ESG/climate index platform to help investors understand and invest in advanced factor and ESG/climate equity strategies. Established by EDHEC-Risk Institute, one of the top academic institutions in the field of fundamental and applied research for the investment industry, Scientific Beta shares the same concern for scientific rigour and veracity, which it applies to all the services that it offers investors and asset managers.
On January 31, 2020, Singapore Exchange (SGX) acquired a majority stake in Scientific Beta. SGX is maintaining the strong collaboration with EDHEC Business School, and principles of independent, empirical-based academic research, that have benefited Scientific Beta’s development to date. Since 2015, Scientific Beta has also been offering highly advanced strategies in the area of ESG and climate change, whether involving options integrated into smart beta indices or pure ESG or climate benchmarks.
As a complement to its own research, Scientific Beta supports an important research initiative developed by EDHEC on ESG and climate investing and cooperates with V.E and ISS ESG for the construction of its ESG and climate indices.
Scientific Beta, 1 George Street, #15-02, Singapore 049145. For further information, please contact: contact@scientificbeta.com, Web: www.scientificbeta.com.
To view this piece of content from www.globenewswire.com, please give your consent at the top of this page.
To view this piece of content from ml-eu.globenewswire.com, please give your consent at the top of this page.
About GlobeNewswire by notified
GlobeNewswire by notified is one of the world's largest newswire distribution networks, specializing in the delivery of corporate press releases financial disclosures and multimedia content to the media, investment community, individual investors and the general public.
Subscribe to releases from GlobeNewswire by notified
Subscribe to all the latest releases from GlobeNewswire by notified by registering your e-mail address below. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Latest releases from GlobeNewswire by notified
Iveco Group signs a 150 million euro term loan facility with Cassa Depositi e Prestiti to support investments in research, development and innovation11.6.2024 12:00:00 CEST | Press release
Turin, 11th June 2024. Iveco Group N.V. (EXM: IVG), a global automotive leader active in the Commercial & Specialty Vehicles, Powertrain and related Financial Services arenas, has successfully signed a term loan facility of 150 million euros with Cassa Depositi e Prestiti (CDP), for the creation of new projects in Italy dedicated to research, development and innovation. In detail, through the resources made available by CDP, Iveco Group will develop innovative technologies and architectures in the field of electric propulsion and further develop solutions for autonomous driving, digitalisation and vehicle connectivity aimed at increasing efficiency, safety, driving comfort and productivity. The financed investments, which will have a 5-year amortising profile, will be made by Iveco Group in Italy by the end of 2025. Iveco Group N.V. (EXM: IVG) is the home of unique people and brands that power your business and mission to advance a more sustainable society. The eight brands are each a
DSV, 1115 - SHARE BUYBACK IN DSV A/S11.6.2024 11:22:17 CEST | Press release
Company Announcement No. 1115 On 24 April 2024, we initiated a share buyback programme, as described in Company Announcement No. 1104. According to the programme, the company will in the period from 24 April 2024 until 23 July 2024 purchase own shares up to a maximum value of DKK 1,000 million, and no more than 1,700,000 shares, corresponding to 0.79% of the share capital at commencement of the programme. The programme has been implemented in accordance with Regulation No. 596/2014 of the European Parliament and Council of 16 April 2014 (“MAR”) (save for the rules on share buyback programmes set out in MAR article 5) and the Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2016/1052, also referred to as the Safe Harbour rules. Trading dayNumber of shares bought backAverage transaction priceAmount DKKAccumulated trading for days 1-25478,1001,023.01489,100,86026:3 June 20247,0001,050.597,354,13027:4 June 20245,0001,055.705,278,50028:6 June20243,0001,096.273,288,81029:7 June 20244,0001,106.174,424,68
Landsbankinn hf.: Offering of covered bonds11.6.2024 11:16:36 CEST | Press release
Landsbankinn will offer covered bonds for sale via auction held on Thursday 13 June at 15:00. An inflation-linked series, LBANK CBI 30, will be offered for sale. In connection with the auction, a covered bond exchange offering will take place, where holders of the inflation-linked series LBANK CBI 24 can sell the covered bonds in the series against covered bonds bought in the above-mentioned auction. The clean price of the bonds is predefined at 99,594. Expected settlement date is 20 June 2024. Covered bonds issued by Landsbankinn are rated A+ with stable outlook by S&P Global Ratings. Landsbankinn Capital Markets will manage the auction. For further information, please call +354 410 7330 or email verdbrefamidlun@landsbankinn.is.
Relay42 unlocks customer intelligence with a new insights and reporting module, powered by Amazon QuickSight11.6.2024 11:00:00 CEST | Press release
AMSTERDAM, June 11, 2024 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Relay42, a leading European Customer Data Platform (CDP), is leveraging Amazon QuickSight to power its new real-time customer intelligence, reporting, and dashboard module. Harnessing the breadth and quality of customer data, the new Insights module empowers marketing teams to dive deep into customer behaviors and gain invaluable insights into the performance of their marketing programs across all online, offline, paid, and owned marketing channels. Preview of the Relay42 Insights module, in pre-beta version Key capabilities of the Relay42 Insights module include: Deep insights into customer behaviors: With the Relay42 Insights module, marketers can ask unlimited questions about their data and gain a deeper understanding of how to serve their customers more effectively. Simplicity with AI-powered querying: Marketers can use artificial intelligence to query their data using natural language search, reducing the reliance on data scientists. Us
Metasphere Labs Announces X Spaces Event on the Topic of Green Bitcoin Mining and Sound Money for Sustainability11.6.2024 10:30:00 CEST | Press release
VANCOUVER, British Columbia, June 11, 2024 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Metasphere Labs Inc. (formerly Looking Glass Labs Ltd., "Metasphere Labs" or the "Company") (Cboe Canada: LABZ) (OTC: LABZF) (FRA: H1N) is thrilled to announce an engaging Twitter Spaces event on Green Bitcoin mining, energy markets, and sustainability on July 3, 2024 at 2 p.m. ET. Follow us on X at MetasphereLabs for updates and to join the event. What We'll Discuss Bitcoin Mining Basics: Understand the fundamentals of Bitcoin mining.Energy Market Dynamics: Explore how Bitcoin mining interacts with energy markets.Sustainable Innovations: Learn about our efforts to promote sustainability in Bitcoin mining.Sound Money: Discover how tamper-proof currency can enhance stability.Efficient Payment Rails: See how fast, neutral payment systems support humanitarian projects.Carbon Footprint: Compare Bitcoin's environmental impact with traditional banking. "We're excited to host this event and dive into the critical topics of Bitcoin